DEBATE: Stay my Baby - Amy or Miranda?

[Paul]

Hey everybody! So I like this song called Stay my Baby. It was originally by Amy Diamond. But Miranda Cosgrove (or the producers of iCarly, it doesn't matter) pretty much stole it for the iCarly soundtrack.

And I wanted to know which version do you like better?

Amy's

Miranda's

- Supergeek  8)

[Chanel]

amys... its just more authentic. and for some reason, mirandas version kind of annoys me...

[Happysimsdude]

Miranda's voice sounds Modified,and that it is a bit too high.
Amy is so unique and I love her voice,its authentic yet her beautiful voice really goes well with the song.
So Amy is a clear winner for me but thats just my oppinion.

[FOBluvr987]

Amy's {yes}

[bambigoddess]

Well, I don't really care for Miranda, and her voice sounds so...messed with. So I'll have to go with Amy's.

[gothika]

Miranda.
I dislike Amy's voice,it's annoying.
But I love it

I'm getting it on iTunes. When I get my USB cord.

[b1245p]

Miranda
And I agree with Pixie I can't stand Amy's voice, it just bugs me for some reason.

[bambigoddess]

Really? Miranda's voice bugs me to no end. At least Amy's is decent. Miranda's just not a singer (or an actress, for that matter, but that's another story ).

[Majick]

I haven't heard this song at all. So I can't give an opinion.

Also, paul, I doubt she "stole" the song. In order for someone to put a song on their Album they HAVE to get the original song writer's permission to do so. If she did steal it, then her producers are in a LOT of trouble. So, don't get all wigged out over this   WHo knows, maybe Amy really liked Miranda's way of remaking the song, maybe Amy is a fan. We don't know everything about these people, after all